23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports have initiated a legal battle against NASCAR, alleging antitrust violations related to the ownership and sale of racing charters. The dispute centers around charters owned by Stewart-Haas Racing, which has decided to downsize, leaving three charters on the market. 23XI, co-owned by Denny Hamlin and Michael Jordan, and Front Row Motorsports, have agreements to purchase these charters to expand their teams. If unresolved, this legal tangle could lead both teams to compete with fewer resources in the 2025 season.
In a recent episode of The Athletic’s ‘The Teardown’ podcast, journalists Jeff Gluck and Jordan Bianchi examined the potential repercussions of this lawsuit on the sport. Bianchi supplied insider information that highlights the interest in SHR’s charters and speculated about possible outcomes. He said:
“The SHR part is certainly interesting and I don’t think you would necessarily see a lawsuit from SHR. From my understanding and the conversations I’ve had with people, people have made inquiries about those charters. Like, ‘Hey, are those available? If they’re available we’re interested in them.’
“So, I don’t think that SHR’s going to be in a spot of, what are we going to do here, we don’t want these, we’re in scramble mode. I think they’re going to have suitors for them. The problem is we’re in mid-December and the season starts in what, eight weeks or whatever it is. So, you’ve got a lot to sort out between that.”
Sean Gardner/Getty Images
The charter system, established by NASCAR in 2016, guarantees teams entry into each points-paying Cup Series race, along with a portion of the prize purse. This system regulates the field size and limits the number of cars a team can own, with charters becoming highly sought-after commodities. Teams holding a charter receive significant financial benefits, an aspect underlined by 23XI and Front Row’s endeavors to secure SHR’s remaining charters. NASCAR’s decision to withhold approval of these sales contingent on the lawsuit being withdrawn is where the contention lies. This move has been perceived as retaliatory.
Financially, charters are increasingly valuable, with recent transactions like Spire Motorsports’ over $40 million purchase demonstrating this. However, ongoing litigation hangs a cloud over their worth. Tony Stewart and Gene Haas, key figures in SHR, might face tough decisions if the dispute harms charter values.
The broader impact of this case is profound. It touches on foundational elements of NASCAR’s operational model, potentially reshaping how charters are managed, while affecting overall competition and financial equity in the sport. The outcome may steer future decisions on revenue split and team ownership structures, setting a challenging precedent.
As the clock ticks closer to the start of the new NASCAR season, parties involved face increasing pressure to reach a resolution. Bianchi expressed optimism that an agreement would materialize before the Daytona race:
“I agree with you, I think this is settled before Daytona. I think that in some way or fashion that an agreement is reached…”
Should the outcome be unfavorable for 23XI and Front Row, they may have to adjust to racing with open cars, devoid of the advantages held by chartered teams. The implications extend beyond competitive disadvantages. Financial stability could also be affected, impacting their operations long-term.
The possible resolution before the Daytona race suggests an inclination towards negotiation.
